Blog
Which Water Filter System Is Right For Your Home?
Expert Opinion
Thursday, September 08, 2011

by Janelle Sorensen, Chief Communications Officer, Healthy Child Healthy World
Healthy Child Healthy World receives a lot of questions from people wondering which water filter they should buy. But, it’s a tough question to answer because drinking water quality varies from place to place, depending on the condition of the source water from which it is drawn and the treatment it receives. It also matters what types of pipes lead up to your home, what kind of pipes and solder are used inside your home, and even what kind of faucets and fixtures you have installed.
Talk about confusing. Every individual faucet releases a distinct glass of water.
Here are 5 steps to help you navigate these muddy waters and find a clear solution for a filtering system.
Step 1: Assess.
If you don’t know what’s in your water, you don’t know what needs filtering out.
- If you rely on a public water utility, you can check the Consumer Confidence Report - which is an annual report that lists the chemicals they test for in your water, as well as how your water is treated. You can also visit the Environmental Working Group’s Tap Water Database and enter your zip code to see what’s been found in your water.
- If you have a private well, it’s up to you to figure out what contaminants might be lurking. Start by calling your local health department, as well as scoping out your neighborhood (look for any potential sources of contamination like pesticides or animal waste from farms, heavy metals and chemicals from mines, industrial effluent, landfills, etc).
Step 2: Test.
Decide if you can use a do-it-yourself kit or if you’ll need to hire a professional to test your water. DIY testing kits that can be found at home improvement and hardware stores are adequate for identifying the presence of some of the most common contaminants. If you’re testing for something more obscure or a wide range of contaminants, you may need a professional’s help. Again, you can call your local public health or environmental quality offices for guidance or you can check with a state certified laboratory.
- Private well owners should test their water at least annually. Some should test more often if there are significant potential changes in water quality (like the seasonal applications of pesticides and fertilizers).
- Everyone should test for lead as it can be present in pipes, solder, and even fixtures. Until you test for lead, let your water run for a minute or two each morning to flush out the water that’s been sitting in the pipes overnight (use that water for your houseplants).
Step 3: Choose.
Once you have your test results, you should first consider the exposure levels. For some contaminants, you may be exposed to much higher levels through everyday products than through water. If you’re concerned about a specific chemical, you may be better off identifying larger exposure sources and focusing on them. If you feel filtration is necessary - look for filters labeled as meeting NSF/ANSI standard 53 and that are certified to remove the contaminant(s) of concern in your water. (Those that meet standard 53 treat water for health, not just for aesthetic qualities like taste or color). The EWG’s Water Filter Buying Guide is a great tool for helping you find the right system for your needs.
There are pitchers, countertop models, under-sink filters, filters that attach directly to your tap, and even whole house models. You might even find that no filter works for your situation. That’s what happened with my family. We tested and found that our water required reverse osmosis to remove the contaminants, but our home didn’t have the water pressure necessary for reverse osmosis. We ended up buying several three and five gallon water bottles (BPA-free) that we fill using filtered water at stations you can find at co-ops and grocery stores.
In regards to the cost of filters, the more expensive filtration systems are sometimes actually cheaper in the long run than the less expensive ones. You have to take into consideration the life span of the filter. Smaller pitcher filters may only have a life span of a hundred gallons, while a larger system may last though several thousand gallons. So, per gallon of water you could be paying over 20 cents with a pitcher and only about 10 cents with a larger system.
Note: No filter removes 100% of contaminants. They can just get very close.
Step 4: Maintain.
Be sure to maintain your filter properly by following the manufacturer’s directions to ensure effectiveness. If you allow contaminants to build up, a filter’s efficacy decreases and it can actually make your water worse by releasing bacteria or chemicals back into your water.
Step 5: Re-assess.
Water quality can change over time. Keep an eye on your local news and health advisories to stay abreast of any conditions that could pose new risks. Here were just a few I found as I researched for this post:
- Labor Day campers at Angeles National Forest left behind tens of thousands of pounds of trash and feces that could end up in the San Gabriel River which supplies 35% of LA’s drinking water.
- The Vermont Department of Public Health is offering free water testing kits to users of private wells that may have been contaminated by flood waters.
- A boil water order has been issued for the Barcelona Water District in Westfield, New York.
- After a pipeline was washed out by recent storms, Rutland City, Vermont’s drinking water reservoir is counting down the days of its drinking water supply. Residents are urged to conserve and will be fined for watering lawns or washing down driveways.
- Only 40 percent of Maine's private wells have been tested for arsenic, but scientists mapping arsenic levels in Maine say the toxin is showing up in more locations than previously suspected, with levels in some wells exceeding the federal safety standard by 10 times -- or more.
Also, remember to take simple steps to reduce your individual impacts on water quality. Do your part by never flushing unused medications or household hazardous waste down the toilet or sink. Check to see if your pharmacy accepts medications for disposal. Also, contact your local health department for information about proper disposal of pharmaceuticals and other materials that could potentially contaminate water, such as cleaning chemicals, pesticides, and automotive products. The safety of one of the most fundamental necessities to all life is in our hands.
Do you use a water filter? What kind?
Posted by Karen B on 09/10/2011 at 10:30 AM
After years of using the Brita, we found out that it does not filter many agriculture pesticides and lead. We live in Ohio and so much of our land is sprayed with toxic pesticides. We use the Get Clean water filter now and most of my friends comment that our water tastes so good. I love that it is also a BPA free pitcher and the filter is made from sustainable sources. After all, what is the use of having pure water if the pitcher has lots of chemicals in it?
Posted by Virginia on 09/09/2011 at 05:26 PM
You can get 3 gallon BPA free bottles at Whole Foods.
Posted by Holly on 09/09/2011 at 04:33 PM
I found 1.25 gal and 2.5 gal slimline H2O containers at Wal Mart. They have no BPA made in USA by Arrowplastic.com. They have a water spout on the front. I fill it with Pi Mag water from Nikken and put in the fridge. They are slim and do not take up much room. Nikken also has a great sport bottle with the filter built in. We take them when we eat out at resturants. Pour their ice water straight into our water bottles. Great tasting water where every we go and we know with out a doubt that it is safe.
Posted by Marian on 09/09/2011 at 01:25 PM
I have used Nikken water filters in my home, and just this summer it proved how important a high quality water filter system is, when I received notice from our local water company, that our system had not met state regulations. I wondered what the odor was coming from the tap, and was grateful that I was not cooking with it, drinking or bathing in it!
Posted by dana on 09/09/2011 at 11:46 AM
In the past, we have used PUR filters that connect to the water faucet. We seemed to be spending a lot of money on replacing the filters often. When we moved homes, we had a different type of faucet, so we had to use a different filter system. We went with GE’s Dual Stage Water Filtration System for under the sink (sold at Home Depot). It is more expensive on the front end, but we are saving a lot of money because we don’t have to change the filters nearly as often. Our water tastes clean and great. I have a home water test kit and it tests clean each time. Less filters = less money and less waste.
And GLASS water bottles is the only way we roll….including my 2 year old son.
We are super happy with our tap water and bottles! Sure beats the plastic stuff any day.
Posted by Tracey on 09/09/2011 at 11:36 AM
There is a key tidbit missing from your article; where did you find BPA-free 3 and 5 gallon water bottles? I’m assuming you are referring to the type of bottle you use on a water cooler, and I’ve never come across a source for ones that are BPA-free. I’ve heard rumours of 3 gallon glass ones, but never seen any for sale. Please share.
More comments:
Get Answers
View AllRead and Learn
It's the trusted guidebook for the Next Generation of Parenting "...that every single parent needs to read..."
PICK UP A COPY
Now In Paperback!







Posted by andrea on 09/12/2011 at 05:09 AM
DOES ANYONE KNOW OF A NON TOXIC CROCK POT? THAT DOES NOT HAVE LEAD, ALUMINUM, ETC.,
THANK YOU VERY MUCH!